Open Access

Dynamic assessment of direct-current mobility in field-assisted sintered oxide dispersion-strengthened V-4Cr-4Ti alloys

International Journal of Mechanical and Materials Engineering201712:14

Received: 3 June 2017

Accepted: 9 July 2017

Published: 24 July 2017



Vanadium alloy is one of the potential candidate material for structural applications in a commercial fusion reactor. Extended survival of a structural material has a direct consequence on the net energy produced in a fusion reaction, it is important to develop ultra-functional materials with tailored microstructures, to meet the harsh fusion environments. Microstructure of material, indeed depend upon the thermodynamics and kinetics of material processing.


Aiming to meet the harsh fusion conditions, we have developed oxide dispersion strengthened V-4Cr-4Ti alloys by high energy ball milling and field assisted sintering technique. Possible microstructural, morphological aftermaths observed in ball milled yttria dispersed V-4Cr-4Ti powders is explored.

Results and conclusion

Electron microscopy and laser particle analysis acknowledge that yttria addition aids powder agglomeration during ball milling. Ball milled powder was then consolidated (to a relative density of ~100%) using field assisted sintering technique, under optimal sintering conditions. Densification profile has implied that heterogeneous powder characteristic (apparent particle size and shape of powder) tends to impede the direct-current conductivity across the powder particle during various stages of field assisted sintering. In order to understand the kinetics of the field assisted sintering process on the starting powders, a new method was developed to compute the activation energy required for the direct-current conductivity across the individual powder particles. Relatively higher activation energy (for direct-current conductivity) is required for sintering yttria dispersed V-4Cr-4Ti powder than its V-4Cr-4Ti counterpart.

Graphical Abstract

Quantitative dynamic sintering kinetics analysis of FAST processed vanadium alloys


Vanadium Yttria Milling Sintering Densification Activation energy


Paybacks of V–4Cr–4Ti alloy as a candidate material in fusion power generation has been extensively discussed elsewhere (Zinkle et al. 2008; Smith et al. 1996; Johnson and Smith 1998; Smith et al. 1995; Muroga et al. 2002). V–4Cr–4Ti alloys have been relentlessly proving themselves as a potential alternative to basic steels and oxide dispersion-strengthened steels owing to their superior performance as a structural material like high temperature mechanical properties, irradiation resistance at elevated temperatures (>400 °C), low activation under fast neutron flux, and high ductility (Chung et al. 1996; Rice and Zinkle 1998; Gelles 1998). Even though the microstructural stability of V–4Cr–4Ti alloys at elevated temperature (>650 °C) is superior to ferritic/martensitic steels, the anticipated power conversion efficiencies expected out of plasma-facing components have increased tremendously (Loomis et al. 1994). This intrigued fusion scientists to look for an ultra-functional V–4Cr–4Ti alloy to withstand harsh conditions inside the fusion reactor, consequently enhancing the power generation efficiency of the same. One such work was attempted in the year 1996, by dispersing ultrafine yttria particles in V–4Cr–4Ti alloy (Yamagata et al. 1996). Shibayama and his co-workers developed the oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) vanadium alloy by a novel powder metallurgy route, namely mechanical-alloying (MA) (Suryanarayana and Norton 1999; Alamo et al. 1992; Miller et al. 2005; Miller et al. 2003; Plant and Steel 1995). Earlier reports have consolidated ODS vanadium alloys using the hot isostatic pressing (HIP) technique, while a recent report suggests that field-assisted sintering (FAST) or spark plasma sintering (SPS) technique offers a variety of microstructural merits that can enhance the high temperature mechanical properties of V–4Cr–4Ti alloys (Krishnan and Sinnaeruvadi 2016). Vital merits offered by the FAST process include self-cleaning of the oxide layer in powder particles before sinter-bonding, retaining the nanostructure, and consolidating the powder particle to full density within a short span of time at lower temperature regimes (Mamedov 2000; Aalund 2008; Yucheng and Zhengyi 2002; Anselmi-tamburini et al. 2005; Chen et al. 2005). But no single literature is available to explain the densification mechanism behind sintering (FAST) V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders. Once the densification mechanism and its associated kinetics behind FAST-processing of the V–4Cr–4Ti powders are understood, tailoring the material properties via FAST process to match fusion-relevant conditions become conceivable (Tong et al. 2009; Thornton 1999; Thornton et al. 2004; Iimura et al. 2009; Yu et al. 1997).

In the present investigation, variations in current consumption while sintering V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders are discussed briefly. Further, the DC (direct-current) conductivity profile while sintering powder was obtained in order to understand the effect of yttria addition on the microstructural and morphological characteristics of ball-milled powders. Finally, the activation energy (E a) required for the sintering current to traverse through the individual powders was deduced.


Powder preparation

Elemental powders of vanadium, titanium, and chromium with a purity of 99.9% and particle size equivalent of −325 mesh size were ball-milled using Retsch, PM-400 planetary ball mill. The typical ball-milling conditions used for synthesizing V–4Cr–4Ti and nano-yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders are presented in Table 1. Ascribed powders in the aforementioned atomic proportions were transferred into tungsten carbide (WC) vials inside the glove box under high pure argon environment (99.99% pure).
Table 1

Ball-milling conditions employed for synthesizing V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders



Type of ball mill

High-energy planetary ball mill

Milling vessel and media

Tungsten carbide (WC)

Plate rotation

250 rpm

Milling time

10 h

Ball-to-powder ratio


Ball-milling atmosphere

High purity argon (99.99% pure)



Powder characterization

Powder morphology, apparent particle size, and chemical composition of ball-milled V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders were studied with the help of scanning electron microscopy images accompanied with energy-dispersive absorptive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM-EDAX). The milled powders were dispersed in ethanol and ultrasonicated for 120 s. The sonicated powders were transferred onto a glass plate and dried in air; subsequently, the powder was transferred onto a carbon tape placed over an aluminum stub and maintained under vacuum 24 h prior to electron microscopy-imaging. From the electron microscopy images, quantitative estimates of apparent particle size (μm) were calculated using ImageJ (version 1.50b) software. Further, to confirm the apparent particle size and its distribution, laser particle size analysis was carried out using Mastersizer 3000 laser diffraction particle size analyzer (Malvern Instruments, UK).

Field-assisted sintering

Ball-milled powders were transferred into the graphite die-punch setup inside the glove box maintained under high pure argon (99.99%) environment. Subsequently, the powder was sintered at 1100 °C for 20 min with a uniaxial pressure of 40 MPa. The relative density of FAST-processed samples was calculated using Archimedes principle. Auxiliary data (recorded every 5 s) with information containing voltage, current, temperature, vacuum, and displacement were recorded during the process. From the auxiliary data, electrical resistivity and conductivity values were computed from the fundamental equations as follows:
$$ R=\rho\ \left(\frac{l}{A}\right) $$
where R is the electrical resistance in ohms calculated from the auxiliary data generated by FAST, ρ is the electrical resistivity in ohm-meter offered by the ball-milled powders during sintering, l is the dynamic sample thickness (linear shrinkage) in millimeter, and A is the cross-sectional area of the sample in square millimeters. Using the dynamic electrical resistivity (ρ) value calculated from Eq. (1), dynamic electrical conductivity σ in mho per meter was calculated from the following equation:
$$ \sigma =\frac{1}{\rho } $$
In order to evaluate the rate constant of a chemical reaction on an absolute scale (Kelvin, K), the Arrhenius equation was used to calculate the activation energy for DC conductivity while sintering ball-milled V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders. The typical Arrhenius equation that was used to plot and compute the activation energy profiles is mentioned below:
$$ \sigma =A \exp \left(\frac{E_{\mathrm{a}}}{K_{\mathrm{b}}T}\right) $$
where, A is the pre-exponential factor, E a is the experimental activation in joules, K b is Boltzmann’s constant (1.3806 × 10−22 J K−1), and T is the absolute temperature in Kelvin. Mathematically, the slope value from the Arrhenius plot is calculated based on the following equation:
$$ \ln \left(\sigma \right)= \ln (A)+\mathrm{slope}.\left(\frac{1}{T}\ \right) $$
The slope value computed by plotting ln(σ dc) in the abscissa and Δ(1/T) in the ordinate is principally used to calculate the activation energy (E a) for DC conductivity as shown below:
$$ {E}_{\mathrm{a}}=-{K}_{\mathrm{b}} \times \mathrm{slope} $$

Results and discussion

Electron microscopy images accompanied with energy-dispersive absorptive spectroscopy (SEM-EDAX) patterns of unmilled (Fig. 1a), milled (Fig. 1b), and yttria-dispersed (Fig. 1c–e) V–4Cr–4Ti powders are presented in Fig. 1. The unmilled powders exhibit irregular shape with an apparent particle size of ~40 μm. The milled powder has resulted in a narrow particle size distribution with an apparent particle size of ~8 μm (Fig. 1b). A steady increment in the apparent particle size with increasing Y2O3 content is noticed. Most importantly, the addition of nano-yttria in the V–4Cr–4Ti powder must have catalyzed the fracturing phenomenon during ball-milling. Upon reaching the limit of comminution, due to very high surface energy, the powder particles must have agglomerated, resulting in a relatively broader apparent particle size distribution. The typical apparent particle sizes of ball-milled powders corresponding to 0.3, 0.6, and 0.9 at.% yttria additions are ~14, ~19, and ~24 μm, respectively (Fig. 1c–e). The apparent particle size (~8 μm) and homogenous shape distribution in the ball-milled V–4Cr–4Ti powders (Fig. 1b) endorse the balance between fracturing and cold-welding phenomena during milling (Yu and Standish 1993). For ball-milling V–4Cr–4Ti powders with varying nano-yttria content, the exponential supremacy of cold-welding (Fig. 1c–e) is evident leading to the agglomeration of powders. Thus, yttria addition could have possibly suppressed the role of a surfactant (NaCl) during ball-milling, leading to excessive cold-welding and the subsequent agglomeration of powders. The EDAX spectra corresponding to the unmilled and milled V–4Cr–4Ti powders reveal the presence of Na and Cl content (Fig. 1b) while the EDAX spectra representing the nano-yttria-dispersed powder show the absence of Na and Cl spectra (Fig. 1c–e). The absence of Na and Cl spectra in the EDAX patterns (Fig. 1c–e) principally confirms the due absence of NaCl’s role as a surfactant/lubricant in the later stages of ball-milling. The absence of surface-active agents (NaCl) must have ramped up the surface tension of powder particles during milling, thereby promoting powder agglomeration (Adams 1994; Mills et al. 2000; Mullier et al. 1991).
Fig. 1

Electron microscopy images accompanied with energy-dispersive absorptive spectroscopy patterns of a unmilled V–4Cr–4Ti powder, b milled V–4Cr–4Ti powder, and V–4Cr–4Ti powder ball-milled with varying yttria content: c 0.3% yttria, d 0.6% yttria, and e 0.9% yttria

Typical outcomes corresponding to the laser particle analysis of V–4Cr–4Ti powders with varying yttria content are presented in Fig. 2 and Table 2. Upon ball-milling, substantial size reduction in the powders is evident and the same can be inferred from the left-sided shift and relatively narrow size distribution profile. Most importantly, while ball-milling the nano-yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders, significant right-sided shift and steady growth in the width of the distribution profile can be observed. Both right-sided shift and growth in the size distribution profile (with yttria addition in the V–4Cr–4Ti powders) approve the clustering or agglomeration of powder particles during milling (Fig. 2 and Table 2). As a point of mention, sintering of powders with a relatively broader particle size distribution can yield relatively dense compacts (close to theoretical density) for a less total linear shrinkage. Ascribed discussion pertaining to the agglomeration of powders with yttria addition strongly concedes with the electron microscopy studies.
Fig. 2

Laser particle analysis of unmilled, milled, and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders

Table 2

Comparison of particle size outcomes obtained from the SEM and laser particle analysis


d SEM (μm)

d LPA (μm)

Unmilled V–4Cr–4Ti powder

40 ± 15

54 ± 9

Milled V–4Cr–4Ti

8 ± 2

12 ± 2.4


14 ± 4

15 ± 1.4


19 ± 7

21 ± 2.4


24 ± 8

27 ± 8.2

d LPA (μm) mean particle size measured using laser particle analyzer, d SEM (μm) mean particle size measured using scanning electron microscopy

Figure 3 reveals the DC conductivity profiles deduced from the auxiliary data generated by the FAST apparatus. DC conductivity profiles clearly demonstrate that yttria addition in the V–4Cr–4Ti powder suppresses the current conductivity across the individual powder particles. Increase in the electrical resistance with varying yttria content can be inferred from the upward shift in the DC conductivity profiles as a function of sintering temperature. Gradual agglomeration of powders and growing complexity in the particle morphology with yttria addition should be the possible reasons behind the upward shift in the DC conductivity profiles.
Fig. 3

DC conductivity profiles computed from the auxiliary data generated from the FAST setup while sintering V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders

The activation energy values computed from the DC conductivity profile is shown in Fig. 4. Yttria addition clearly shoots up the E a values for current conduction (DC conductivity) across the powder particles during FAST-processing. The gradual increment in the E a values with increasing yttria content (from 0.3 to 0.9 at.%) clearly indicates the sluggish electromigration phenomenon across the individual powder particles (ODS vanadium powders) during sintering. Apart from the particle size and shape effect, yttria addition must have principally increased the population of metal-to-ceramic interfaces. Since the electrical conductivity across the metal-to-metal and the metal-to-ceramic interface is different altogether during sintering, the population of metal-to-ceramic interfaces could have possibly delayed (or suppressed) the subsequent stages of sintering, viz. spark discharge, formation of ionization column, vaporization, localized neck formation, plastic deformation, mass transport via ionization column (surface and volume diffusion), and solidification. Ascribed stages of sintering solely depend on the DC current conduction and its associated joule-heating phenomenon across the powders. Even if one stage gets delayed, overlapping of the subsequent stages of sintering can lead to poor sintering kinetics henceforth. The poorer the sintering kinetics, the lower will be the driving force for electromigration across the powders. If we compare the activation energy (E a) values for DC current conduction of V–4Cr–4Ti (0.00084 eV) and V–4Cr–4Ti–0.9Y2O3 (0.034 eV) powders, by adding 0.9 at.% of yttria in V–4Cr–4Ti, the activation barrier required for DC current conduction across the powder particles has increased by 40 times. The solid line (see Fig. 4) indicating the activation energy profile of the V–4Cr–4Ti powder is relatively much steeper than the activation profiles of ODS vanadium powders. A steeper activation profile (V–4Cr–4Ti powder) indicates excellent DC current conduction across the powder particles during sintering. On the other hand, when the yttria content is gradually increased from 0.3 to 0.9 at.%, the activation profile becomes significantly flat indicating a higher activation barrier (or poor sintering kinetics). Even though the increase in yttria content has led to an inhomogeneous and larger particle size, the samples have achieved relative density close to the theoretical density with relatively lesser shrinkage/densification. The apparent relative densities of FAST-processed samples, viz. V–4Cr–4Ti, V–4Cr–4Ti–0.3Y2O3, V–4Cr–4Ti–0.6Y2O3, and V–4Cr–4Ti–0.9Y2O3, sintered at identical sintering conditions are found to be ~98%.
Fig. 4

Activation energy (E a) profiles of V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders depicting the suppression of sintering current (DC conductivity) as a function of varying yttria content in starting powders, during FAST process


V–4Cr–4Ti and yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti powders have been synthesized by ball-milling and consolidated using FAST process. Yttria addition has principally suppressed the surfactant’s role as a process control agent during milling, resulting in powder agglomeration and the subsequent increase in the apparent particle size distribution. Electron microscopy imaging and laser particle size analysis of ball-milled powders do endorse the increase in the apparent particle size with varying yttria content in V–4Cr–4Ti powder. The steady increment in the apparent particle size distribution of ball-milled powders (with varying yttria content) has attributed an exponential increase in the current consumption during the FAST process. Hence, the magnitude of sintering current consumption (for sintering the discussed powders) during the FAST process can be seen as a function of yttria content in V–4Cr–4Ti powders. For the given sintering condition, FAST-processing of V–4Cr–4Ti powders consume a relatively low order of current when compared with its yttria-dispersed V–4Cr–4Ti counterpart. Activation energy values computed from the DC current conductivity profile also confirms the fact that yttria addition (0.3 to 0.9 at.%) steadily increases the insulation resistance for DC current conductivity during FAST process.


  • Novel method developed for computing activation energy during sintering

  • Effect of yttria-doping (in V–4Cr–4Ti) on DC conductivity during sintering

  • Yttria addition in V–4Cr–4Ti powder leads to powder agglomeration

  • Powder characteristics affect dynamic current mobility during sintering


Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.

Authors’ Affiliations

Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, National Institute of Technology


  1. Aalund, R. (2008). Spark plasma sintering. Ceramic Industry magazine. 158, 607–610.Google Scholar
  2. Adams, MJ. (1994). Agglomerate compression strength measurement test using a uniaxial confined. 78, 5–13.Google Scholar
  3. Alamo, A, Regle, H, Pons, G, & Béchade, JL (1992). Microstructure and textures of ODS ferritic alloys obtained by mechanical alloying. In Materials Science Forum (Vol. 88, pp. 183-190). Trans Tech Publications.Google Scholar
  4. Anselmi-tamburini, U, Gennari, S, Garay, JE, & Munir, ZA (2005). Fundamental investigations on the spark plasma sintering/synthesis process II. Modeling of current and temperature distributions. 394, 139–148.Google Scholar
  5. Chen, W, Anselmi-Tamburini, U, Garay, JE, Groza, JR, & Munir, ZA. (2005). Fundamental investigations on the spark plasma sintering/synthesis process. Materials Science and Engineering: A, 394(1-2), 132–138.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  6. Chung, HM, Loomis, BA, & Smith, DL (1996). Development and testing of vanadium alloys for fusion applications. 239, 139–156.Google Scholar
  7. Gelles, DS (1998). Microstructural examination of irradiated V ± (4 ± 5%) Cr ± (4 ± 5%) Ti. 263, 1380–1385.Google Scholar
  8. Iimura, K, Suzuki, M, Hirota, M, & Higashitani, K. (2009). Higashitani, Simulation of dispersion of agglomerates in gas phase – acceleration field and impact on cylindrical obstacle, Advanced Powder Technology, 20(2), 210–5.Google Scholar
  9. Johnson, WR, & Smith, JP (1998). Fabrication of a 1200 kg ingot of V ± 4Cr ± 4Ti alloy for the DIII ± D radiative divertor program. 263, 1425–1430.Google Scholar
  10. Krishnan, VK, Sinnaeruvadi, K, NU SC, RMHM (2016).
  11. Loomis, BA, Chung, HM, Nowicki, LJ, & Smith, DL (1994). !!!! I. 3115(94), 2–6.Google Scholar
  12. Mamedov, V. (2000). Spark plasma sintering as advanced PM sintering method.Google Scholar
  13. Miller, MK, Kenik, EA, Russell, KF, Heatherly, L, Hoelzer, DT, & Maziasz, PJ (2003). Atom probe tomography of nanoscale particles in ODS ferritic alloys. 353, 140–145.Google Scholar
  14. Miller, MK, Hoelzer, DT, Kenik, EA, & Russell, KF (2005). Stability of ferritic MA/ODS alloys at high temperatures. 13, 387–392.Google Scholar
  15. Mills, PJT, Seville, JPK, Knight, PC, & Adams, MJ (2000). The effect of binder viscosity on particle agglomeration in a low shear mixer agglomerator. 140–147.
  16. Mullier, MA, Seville, JPK, & Adams, MJ (1991). The effect of agglomerate on attrition during processing. 65, 321–333.Google Scholar
  17. Muroga, T, Nagasaka, T, Abe, K, Chernov, VM, Matsui, H, Smith, DL, Xu, ZY, & Zinkle, SJ. (2002). Vanadium alloys—overview and recent results. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 307–311(1 SUPPL), 547–554.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  18. Plant, CL, & Steel, K (1995). Dispersion behaviour of oxide particles in mechanically alloyed ODS steel. 14, 1600–1603.Google Scholar
  19. Rice, PM, & Zinkle, SJ (1998). Temperature dependence of the radiation damage microstructure in V ± 4Cr ± 4Ti neutron irradiated to low dose. 263, 1414-1419.Google Scholar
  20. Smith, DL, Chung, HM, Loomis, BA, Matsui, H, Votinov, S, Witzenburg, WV (1995). Fusion engineering and design development of vanadium-base alloys for fusion first-wall-blanket applications, 3796 (94).Google Scholar
  21. Smith, DL, Chung, HM, & Loomis, BA (1996). b ! fY, 15(96).
  22. Suryanarayana, C, & Norton, MG. (1999). Book review X-ray diffraction : a practical approach (pp. 13–15).
  23. Thornton, C. (1999). Numerical simulations of agglomerate impact breakage (pp. 74–82).Google Scholar
  24. Thornton, C, Ciomocos, MT, & Adams, MJ. (2004). Numerical simulations of diametrical compression tests on agglomerates. 140, 258–267.Google Scholar
  25. Tong, ZB, Yang, RY, Yu, AB, Adi, S, & Chan, HK. (2009). Numerical modelling of the breakage of loose agglomerates of fine particles. Powder Technology, 196(2), 213–221.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  26. Yamagata, I, Kurishita, H, & Kayano, H (1996). Development of oxide dispersion strengthened vanadium alloy and its properties. 239, 162–169.Google Scholar
  27. Yu, A. B., Bridgwater, J., & Burbidge, A (1997). On the modelling of the packing of fine particles. Powder technology, 92 (3), 185–194.Google Scholar
  28. Yu, AB, & Standish, N (1993). Characterisation of non-spherical particles from their packing behaviour. 74, 205–213.Google Scholar
  29. Yucheng, W, & Zhengyi, F (2002). Study of temperature field in spark plasma sintering. 90, 34–37.Google Scholar
  30. Zinkle, SJ, Matsui, H, Smith, DL, Rowcli, AF, Osch, EV, Abe, K, & Kazakov, VA (2008). Research and development on vanadium alloys for fusion applications. 263, 205-214.Google Scholar


© The Author(s). 2017