Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of SCF of radial circular cross bore at the vessel intersection (Makulsawatudom et al., 2004; Masu, 1991)

From: Cross bore geometry configuration effects on stress concentration in high-pressure vessels: a review

K

Gerdeen (1972) (photo elasticity)

Fessler and Lewin (1956) (analytical)

Faupel and Harris (1957) (strain gage and photoelasticity 2D & 3D)

Peterson (1974) (strain gage)

Tan and Fenner (1980) (boundary integral element (BIE))

Abdul-Mihsein and Fenner (1983) (BIE)

Masu (1991) (3D FEA)

Chaaban and Burns (1986) (3D FEA)

Makulsawatudom et al. (2004) (3D FEA) hole size ratio \( \frac{R_C}{b}=0.01 \)

Makulsawatudom et al. (2004) (3D FEA) hole size ratio \( \frac{R_{\mathrm{C}}}{b}=0.05 \)

1.4

2.99

2.84

1.5

3.19

3.08

3.40

2.82

2.73

1.75

3.26

2.93

2.83

2.0

3.32

3.4

3.02

3.44

2.98

2.97–3.0

3.03

3.58

3.04

2.89

2.25

3.51

2.53

3.13

2.91

2.5

3.59

2.54

3.69

3.20

2.94

3

3.70

2.51

3.78